ACCESS TO THE MEMBER’S AREA CONTENT IS FREE: You can now read any news, and view all the shows from around the world inside the News & Show Reports sections!
Friday, 22 May 2020

The Dutch KC in violation of FCI rules

Featured Written by Edwin Meyer Viol

On a recent social media post, Edwin stated,  “The decision of the Dutch Kennel Club, not to issue pedigrees from May 18th 2020.

Is in our opinion a violation of the regulations of the FCI, the umbrella organisation of the kennel clubs from all over the world.”  Following OUR DOGS front-page story in May 15th where the whole situation was highlighted, OUR DOGS asked Edwin to explain…


In the Netherlands, the government had enforcement criteria drawn up by the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine of the University of Utrecht, to prohibit breeding with brachycephalic dogs. 
The dogs are condemned on the nose length in the CFR. In short, the CFR indicates the ratio between nose length and skull length. If it is below 0.3 then it is not allowed to breed with the dog. The University of Utrecht assumes that there is a causal relationship between nose length and BOAS, the disease that concerns respiratory problems that occur in dogs with a short muzzle.


The Dutch Kennel Club deceives the FCI in our view, by saying that it is allowed to breed from Brachycephalic dogs with CFR>0,3 and denies the generalist principles of the law. This cannot take away that the Dutch Kennel Club makes a public statement that it concerns 12 breeds. In short, they acknowledge that they agree with the generalist and discriminatory principles of the enforcement criteria of the minister who denies the integrity of every dog on its own. The FCI does not. This should lead to a confrontation between the Dutch Kennel Club and the FCI.

The Dutch Government does not prohibit the issue of pedigrees.

A pedigree is a proof of parentage, to be issued by the Dutch Kennel Club according to its contractual obligation towards both the breeders and the FCI. That it is not forbidden by law to issue this pedigree, is confirmed by the Kennel Club by issuing another, an adjusted proof of parentage which clearly states that it is not a pedigree. In doing so, the Kennel Club goes further than the government. This pedigree ban for brachycephalic dogs has been introduced without consultation with its members, the breed associations concerned, as well as with the FCI. This ‘misstep’ could hurt the Dutch Kennel Club deeply.


The Dutch Kennel Club is in a difficult position. Partly due to its position in relation to other members of Fairdog (a group, that once again, tries to bring healthy and responsible bred dogs onto the market) including the action/ activist group ‘Animal and Law (Dier en Recht). An impossible position has arisen due to the continuing attacks of the action group, to refuse pedigrees to the short-muzzled breeds. It is known to ‘Animal and Law’ that pedigrees are a weak spot for the pedigree breeders. They set out with the goal to bring down pedigrees. As a cross-breeder stated correctly ‘the Dutch Kennel Club has become an ocean steamer in the canals of Amsterdam’. Their freedom of movement is limited on all sides. This continuous navigation makes it impossible to manoeuvre hence the position they are in now.


We cannot deny that the Dutch Kennel Club must keep pedigrees of dogs that comply with the breeds and standard, recognized by the FCI. (see Article 20.13 of the Statutes and Article 20.1 of the Standing Order). There is only one exception possible; if the dog suffers from hereditary diseases (see article 20.5 of the Standing Order). However, by refusing pedigrees to breeds instead of dogs, the Dutch Kennel Club cannot use this exemption rule, because they cannot demonstrate that the dog meets this exclusion criterion. The very real danger for the FCI, is that if the Dutch Kennel Club gets away with this exemption rule, the FCI implicitly recognizes the Dutch enforcement criteria of the Brachy breeds and thus ban all of them, yes ALL of the brachycephalic breeds. A consequence which, in our opinion, would not be welcomed by the rest of the world. This seems to me both an unthinkable situation, but equally not the intention of this exemption possibility.

In short, if the Dutch Kennel Club does not register any more pedigrees of the brachycephalic breeds, it is acting contrary to article 20.13 of the Statutes and 20.1 of the Standing orders and/or it does not recognize all breeds of the FCI, which is also contrary to the Statutes. Because of this, the Dutch Kennel Club no longer complies with the condition to be a member of the FCI


And then there’s another misunderstanding:
The point that the Dutch Kennel Club states in one of its publications that they are disappointed that our government doesn’t ban the import of the short-muzzled breeds apparently surprised the president of the FCI.
‘The Dutch Kennel Club regrets that the minister does not implement the necessary additional regulations for example on the import of short muzzled dogs’ writes the Dutch Kennel Club.

The irony is, by telling apparent half-truths to the FCI, it back fires. After all, the Dutch Kennel Club is probably thinking of all the puppy mill dogs and look-a-likes that are now allowed to cross the Dutch border freely while the FCI president could be thinking of the short-muzzled pedigree dogs. Both are right because an import ban would hit both categories. A conversation between the two organisations is going to be really necessary.

A quote from the FCI chairman Tamás Jakkel on social media:
“accepting the national legislation is one thing but calling for more, needs a serious discussion with our member”


The upcoming meeting between the FCI and the Dutch Kennel Club could already have two items on the agenda. We hope, a constructive and open discussion between both parties, but it seems to me that the Dutch Kennel Club should put its intention to refuse pedigrees as of the 18th of May on hold until after the meeting.

Going radically against the obligations of the Dutch Kennel Club with the FCI seems to me something that can not only be decided by the board of the Dutch Kennel Club, but something that requires a general meeting of members and breed clubs concerned. After all, it is no longer just about the Netherlands, but it has consequences for all countries and Kennel Clubs that are members of the FCI.

by Edwin Meyer Viol
Stichting Ras en Recht
Foundation Breed and Justice

Edwin Meyer Viol is the Founder of the 
foundation ‘Ras en Recht’ which means 
‘justice for the breeds’ and has researched and written on dog breeds and particularly on the subject of Brachycephalic breeds 

FOOTNOTE:  The statutes of the FCI:
‘20.13. The pedigrees issued by a Member or a Contract Partner must be accepted by all the Members and Contract Partners as “documents proving that the pups are born of pedigree parents from the same breed’.
In the standing orders of the FCI:
Article 20 - Studbooks
20.1. Every Member and Contract Partner must keep a studbook for all the breeds recognised on a definitive basis by the FCI
20.5. Any Member or Contract Partner can refuse to (re)-register in its studbook, or alternatively can (re-)register with a “limited registration: not to be used for breeding”, a DOG suffering from hereditary defects or featuring defects which go against the Article 3 of the Statutes or a dog which does not comply with the rules of selection defined by the Member or Contract Partner in question.


Read 1277 times Last modified on Tuesday, 26 May 2020

Digital Editions

Latest Shows

  • FCI World Rescue Dog Championship
    FCI World Rescue Dog Championship The FCI Rescue Dog World Championship has started in Slovakia! This year's individual World Cup, there is also a team World Cup, but these follow each other every year. The…
  • 148th Annual Westminster Show
    148th Annual Westminster Show A smart Miniature Poodle called Sage took Best in Show at the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show presented by Purina Pro Plan. GCHG CH Surrey Sage, handled by Kaz Hosaka…
  • Szilvásvárad 2024
    Szilvásvárad 2024 Our Dogs SZV Szilvásvárad Hungary report The Szilvásvárad exhibition has always been an important event for dog breeding in Hungary, unfortunately the main organizer of the exhibition, András Korózs, the…


Newsletter Signup!

Purchase Our Dogs

ODi Sponsors

Unique shampoos and conditioners


Our Clients


Newsletter Signup!

For a weekly newsletter packed with the latest and newest dog relating info, show reports, and up and coming shows. Plus offers and other information. Subscribe below

cloudMore about Our Dogs International

This dedicated international dog-showing website is brought to you by Our Dogs one of the most respected dog media brands in Europe today. Features; up & coming dog shows in our partners section, plus show reports and photos after the shows have finished!

You will be able to view a vast range of photos taken at the shows by our top dog photographers, as well as show results from the shows & judges' reports and write-ups from leading contributors.